Dutch phd thesis

Laudatio phd defense

I believe this happened around January , and my defense was scheduled for June We must protect academic freedom, not make it suspect. In my case, two committee members had suggestions for revisions. But, this committee member responded way after the deadline, so since all the other committee members had approved, I had already printed my thesis. Moreover, the questions that will be asked are sometimes even given to the students in advance. However, this examiner was not supposed to know the candidate too well, but in French's case, they were well acquainted: 'Before the defence he said to me, 'for what I'm about to do' please don't take it personally''. That was a reference to the long-running controversy over Dutch universities teaching some courses in English — a hot-button cultural identity issue for some on the right. French smiles as he recalls wearing a suit and a fancy blue and purple toga, despite the hot June sunshine and his reputation as a 'scruffy sod' who loathed pompous display: 'Like the other PhD graduates, I was invited on the stage to have the vice-chancellor wrap his hands around mine'. Because this bluntness is normal for PhD defences in the Netherlands and rather fits our image of being very direct, it was funny that many of my friends and family were quite shocked by it! Hora est is when the fun begins — first with a laudatio a speech by your supervisor , then a reception, and usually a party.

We must protect academic freedom, not make it suspect. No need anymore to choose tall, burly paranimfen! In the worst case, a candidate must schedule a second defence, which is unthinkable in the Netherlands, where candidates probably wouldn't even fail 'if they were dumbstruck'.

Paranymph phd defense

Since I spent the last year of my PhD revising papers , I was quite happy to choose the easier but just as effective option. In the worst case, a candidate must schedule a second defence, which is unthinkable in the Netherlands, where candidates probably wouldn't even fail 'if they were dumbstruck'. In my case, two committee members had suggestions for revisions. Graduation ceremonies in the UK are similar to those in the United States. The thesis consisted of a large body of multidisciplinary, original studies of excellent quality, resulting in new insights in the role of diet and vascular determinants of Alzheimer disease. The Dutch PhD defence is very formal: there is a protocol to be followed, stipulating what happens at every step, what you should say at the beginning and at the end, and how you should address your opponents. In the Netherlands, PhD candidates defend their dissertations during a traditional public ceremony. By the way, this is why it is a very good idea to prepare pieces of paper with the name of each opponent and the way you should address them. This is a a relatively normal number, since you give copies to people from your department or in your field. I believe this happened around January , and my defense was scheduled for June Kiliaan , Geriatric medicine Co-supervisor: Dr.

Although the event's festive character should be valued, PhD candidates need to be exposed to more public criticism, according to some foreign professors at TU Delft. One of the quirks of the Dutch PhD defence is that you have two paranimfen at your side to answer questions for you if you get unwell, or even to physically defend you if the argument gets out of hand.

Dutch phd thesis

One of the quirks of the Dutch PhD defence is that you have two paranimfen at your side to answer questions for you if you get unwell, or even to physically defend you if the argument gets out of hand. She also is the one who comes back after an hour to rescue you, stamping the mace on the ground and calling Hora est before leading the examiners out again. One committee member suggested a few points for the discussion, but also said that the thesis was approved regardless of whether I had time to implement them. In the worst case, a candidate must schedule a second defence, which is unthinkable in the Netherlands, where candidates probably wouldn't even fail 'if they were dumbstruck'. But that is not what diversity is about. Carmona's PhD defence took place in Delft and, besides being in English, was very much a typical Dutch ceremony. Being performed at the departments of Anatomy Co-supervisor: Dr. The Dutch PhD defence is very formal: there is a protocol to be followed, stipulating what happens at every step, what you should say at the beginning and at the end, and how you should address your opponents. Melody would be 'mortally embarrassed' if one of his North American students needed a second defence, because 'to be allowed to defend is the most important quality criterion. It was quite a happening, what with the pedel, seven examiners in full academic dress, two paranimfen to support me, and all m y friends and family present. Wiesmann and unanimously decided to award him the Thesis Prize She in my case carries the ceremonial mace and leads the external examiners to their place. The jury was impressed by the high quality of the research, the timely topic and scope of approaches used by Dr.

The main things you need is a thesis. Half way through his PhD course, he had to defend a mini-thesis, which was given by his supervisor and one internaldepartment examiner.

Phd defence

French smiles as he recalls wearing a suit and a fancy blue and purple toga, despite the hot June sunshine and his reputation as a 'scruffy sod' who loathed pompous display: 'Like the other PhD graduates, I was invited on the stage to have the vice-chancellor wrap his hands around mine'. A bad dissertation reflects very badly on the student's supervisor'. It generally takes place in the university Aula. Amanda J. The Examination Board will then withdraw to deliberate. Half way through his PhD course, he had to defend a mini-thesis, which was given by his supervisor and one internaldepartment examiner. At the appointed hour, the Beadle Pedel, in Dutch will lead the Doctoral Examination Board into the room where the defence will be held. Carmona, who works at the faculty of Architecture, found it frustrating to have to explain so many 'irrelevant' issues, but believes her dissatisfaction is not unusual: 'Many of my colleagues refuse to discuss their PhD exams'. From what I understand, my experience is representative for computer science and other technical PhDs in the Netherlands. French's final defence was a private occasion lacking all ceremony and merely involving three examiners, who asked 'very reasonable' questions for one hour. Approval After getting thesis. You have a year to do that and only then you are officially awarded your degree.

She in my case carries the ceremonial mace and leads the external examiners to their place. And that is after exactly an hour — no matter who is speaking. Carmona's PhD defence took place in Delft and, besides being in English, was very much a typical Dutch ceremony.

paranymph dress code

However, the yearly formal graduation ceremony compensates for the lack of festivities surrounding the PhD defence. Melody would be 'mortally embarrassed' if one of his North American students needed a second defence, because 'to be allowed to defend is the most important quality criterion.

Family, friends and colleagues had gathered in one of the Aula's formal halls and saw the pedel master of ceremony lead the defence committee into the room.

dutch phd defense

I believe this happened around Januaryand my defense was scheduled for June

Rated 8/10 based on 88 review
Download
Rules and regulations for PhD candidates